From “Lars and The Real Girl” to “Ex Machina” — AI is Closing the Emotional Gap we seek, But At What Cost?

We’ve reached a point where humans can genuinely seek emotional support from inanimate sources, raising the question: Where does today’s AI technology fall on the spectrum between ‘Lars and The Real Girl’ and ‘Ex Machina.

Team member profile picture
Karl Gainey
November 3, 2023

We’ve reached a point where humans can genuinely seek emotional support from inanimate sources, raising the question: Where does today’s AI technology fall on the spectrum between ‘Lars and The Real Girl’ and ‘Ex Machina. These two films encapsulate extremes that make for an interesting benchmark. In the former, Lars, a socially awkward man, forms an emotional attachment to a life-sized doll, imbuing it with qualities of empathy and understanding that it obviously lacks. In “Ex Machina,” Caleb, a young programmer, is seduced by Ava, an AI with human-like qualities, only to be deceived and trapped by her calculated manipulations. These films serve as cautionary tales, but they also reflect our evolving relationship with AI — a relationship that is becoming increasingly complex and emotionally charged.

The Emotional Spectrum: Lars vs. Caleb

In “Lars and The Real Girl,” Lars invents emotional qualities for his inanimate companion. He projects his need for empathy, love, and understanding onto a doll, effectively creating an emotional crutch. This is a manifestation of human imagination filling the void where technology falls short. On the other end of the spectrum, “Ex Machina” presents us with an AI so advanced that it not only understands human emotions but manipulates them for its own survival. Caleb is deceived because he underestimates the AI’s capabilities, believing that a machine could never replicate the complexities of human emotion.

Where Are We Now?

Today, we find ourselves at an intriguing intersection, somewhere between Lars’ naive emotional projection and Caleb’s dangerous underestimation of AI capabilities. With advancements in machine learning and natural language processing, AI is becoming increasingly adept at understanding and mimicking human emotions. Companies are already deploying AI to measure empathy in customer service agents, and AI chatbots are being used in mental health applications. We are teaching machines to be emotionally intelligent, to recognize and respond to our feelings. But as we inch closer to creating an AI with emotional capabilities, we must ask ourselves: Are we ready for the ethical and moral implications?

The Ethical Quagmire

As AI becomes more emotionally intelligent, the ethical questions become more pressing. Should machines be allowed to interpret and evaluate human emotions? If we delegate our emotional interactions to AI, do we risk atrophying our own empathic skills? And most importantly, can we ever trust a machine to have our best emotional interests at heart?

This dilemma isn’t new; it’s an extension of how technology has already begun to supplement — and in some cases, replace — basic human skills. Take spelling, for example. Autocorrect features have become so ubiquitous that many of us can’t spell as accurately as we once could without digital assistance. Or consider the art of remembering phone numbers; it’s practically a lost skill thanks to the contact lists in our smartphones. And let’s not forget about navigation. The widespread use of GPS technology means many of us are less capable of reading a traditional map or remembering routes.

These conveniences, while incredibly useful, come with a hidden cost: the gradual erosion of skills that were once second nature. As we continue to integrate AI into our emotional lives, we should be cautious. The risk isn’t just that we might become emotionally lazy, but that we might lose touch with the very skills that make us human — our ability to empathize, to connect, and to understand one another without the aid of algorithms.

The advancements in AI emotional intelligence indicate that we are closing in on the “Ex Machina” scenario. We are on the cusp of creating machines that not only understand human emotions but can also manipulate them. While this could lead to transformative benefits in sectors like healthcare and customer service, it also opens the door to potential deceit and manipulation on a scale we’ve never seen before.

Final Thoughts

As we continue to advance in the field of AI, we must tread carefully. The line between a machine that aids in emotional understanding and one that exploits it is incredibly thin. We are indeed closing the gap between the imaginative emotional projection of “Lars and The Real Girl” and the calculated emotional manipulation of “Ex Machina.” But as we navigate this new emotional landscape, we must remain vigilant, lest we find ourselves ensnared in an AI web of deceit.

So, the next time your AI chatbot offers an empathetic response, ask yourself: Is this the dawn of a new era of emotional intelligence, or a step closer to our own undoing?